Selecting the correct hardness for a suction couch roll cover is an important engineering decision for paper mills. The cover must suit the forming-section operating environment, including machine speed, vacuum-assisted dewatering, forming-fabric contact, water exposure, mechanical loading, and wear conditions.
A common mistake in roll-cover procurement is to treat Shore A and P&J hardness as interchangeable values. They are different measurement systems. P&J (Pusey and Jones) measures indentation on a rubber-covered roller. Its numerical direction is inverse: lower P&J values indicate harder covers, while higher values indicate softer covers.
The correct hardness should therefore be determined from the actual application, the existing OEM specification, the cover formulation, and a consistent testing procedure.
P&J hardness is an indentation measurement used for rubber-covered rollers. Under the applicable test procedure, a specified indenter applies a defined force to the cover, and the resulting indentation is measured.
Shore A hardness uses a different durometer method. Although approximate comparison charts exist, a P&J reading should not simply be substituted with a Shore A value.
ISO 48-8:2018 specifies the Pusey and Jones method for determining the apparent hardness of vulcanized or thermoplastic rubber-covered rollers.
When preparing a purchase specification, identify:
Hardness scale: P&J or Shore A.
Nominal hardness value.
Permitted tolerance.
Applicable test standard.
Test temperature.
Cover thickness.
Number and location of readings.
Required inspection report.
This information helps prevent misunderstandings between paper mills, engineering teams, and roll-cover suppliers.
Remember: a lower P&J number means a harder cover. A higher P&J number means a softer cover.
A suction couch roll operates in the forming section, where the sheet, forming fabric, water drainage, and vacuum system interact.
The cover should be selected according to its actual duty.
Machine speed and mechanical conditions
Provide normal and maximum operating speed, roll diameter, face length, mechanical loading, and any known vibration or deflection issues.
Higher operating speed can increase the importance of dynamic stability, cover bonding, and the mechanical properties of the elastomer. The complete roll assembly should be assessed rather than evaluating hardness independently.
Vacuum and dewatering
Review the operating vacuum, suction zones, hole arrangement, suction-box design, and forming-fabric condition.
Dewatering performance is influenced by the complete forming system. Changing hardness alone cannot guarantee improved sheet dryness or drainage.
Water and chemical exposure
Identify water conditions, cleaning agents, chemicals, temperature, and contamination. These factors may influence the cover's resistance to ageing, swelling, and material degradation.
Hardness does not fully describe the performance of a roll cover. Two compounds with similar P&J values may behave differently because their formulations have different mechanical and chemical properties.
Rubber cover evaluation should include resilience, abrasion resistance, tear strength, bonding, and resistance to the operating environment.
Polyurethane cover evaluation should consider abrasion resistance, mechanical strength, hydrolysis resistance, temperature, and chemical compatibility.
Neither material should be regarded as automatically superior. The correct choice depends on the roll position, process requirements, and material formulation.
A reliable selection process should begin with the original specification.
Review the OEM drawing, existing hardness records, cover material, maintenance history, and actual operating conditions.
Inspect the old cover for uneven wear, cracks, surface deterioration, changes in roughness, and possible delamination. Remember that an aged in-service cover may have a different measured hardness from its original manufactured condition.
Next, discuss the proposed hardness with the supplier. Ask how the recommendation relates to the machine's operating conditions and material formulation.
Finally, establish the acceptance procedure. Specify the P&J test method, nominal value, tolerance, test temperature, measurement locations, and reporting requirements.
Keep the inspection records as a reference for future maintenance and replacement projects.
Q1. What P&J hardness should I choose for a suction couch roll?
There is no universal value suitable for every suction couch roll. The correct hardness depends on roll function, material formulation, machine speed, vacuum conditions, contact loading, forming-fabric requirements, and the original machine specification. A supplier should review these conditions before recommending a target value.
Q2. Is P&J the same as Shore A?
No. P&J and Shore A use different measurement principles. P&J measures indentation on a rubber-covered roller, whereas Shore A uses a durometer. The numerical values cannot be substituted directly without an agreed comparison method and technical verification.
Q3. Does a lower P&J value mean harder rubber?
Yes. P&J is an inverse indentation scale. A lower value indicates less indentation and a harder cover. A higher value indicates greater indentation and a softer cover. This distinction should be made clear in every RFQ and inspection document.
Q4. Does hardness directly determine dewatering performance?
No. Dewatering also depends on vacuum conditions, suction-hole geometry, forming fabric, machine speed, sheet characteristics, and the overall forming-section design. Hardness is one variable in a larger system and should not be changed without reviewing the complete application.
Q5. Which is better, rubber or polyurethane?
Neither is universally better. Rubber and polyurethane formulations have different resilience, abrasion resistance, tear strength, and chemical compatibility. The correct material should be selected according to operating conditions and verified technical requirements.
Q6. Can an old cover's measured hardness be used as the new cover specification?
It can be a useful reference, but the old cover may have aged or deteriorated. Compare its original manufacturing records with the current measurement and inspection results. Do not automatically copy an in-service reading into a new manufacturing specification.
Q7. How should I specify hardness tolerance?
State the nominal P&J value, allowable deviation, applicable standard, test temperature, and measurement locations. Agree on the inspection procedure with the supplier before manufacturing so both parties use consistent acceptance criteria.
Q8. What information should I provide when requesting a quotation?
Provide the roll drawing, machine position, diameter, face length, speed range, vacuum conditions, forming-fabric information, existing material, hardness specification, and observed wear condition. Include inspection requirements and identify any missing information.
Conclusion
The correct P&J hardness for a suction couch roll cover must be determined through application-specific engineering evaluation. Machine speed, vacuum conditions, forming-fabric contact, mechanical loading, material formulation, and testing requirements should all be considered.
Avoid treating Shore A and P&J as equivalent or choosing hardness solely from a generic chart. A clearly documented specification and consistent inspection procedure provide a better basis for replacement-roll quality and long-term maintenance.
Related Products
Contact HUATAO
Tony Liu | International Department
Mobile / WhatsApp / WeChat: +86 13383112591
Email: sale08@huataogroup.com
Website: www.huataorolls.com
HUATAO welcomes customers from around the world to discuss their paper-machine roll requirements. Send your technical drawings, operating conditions, and existing cover specifications to begin a project review.
can not be empty
can not be empty